image doctor
Image Doctor: Pondering Milford
|
Photographer: Christopher Ojala Added: 01-Aug-12 Camera Type: Pentax K-5 Lens: Sigma 18-55mm Shutter Speed: 1/250 Aperture: f/7.1 |
Adjustments: Sharpened and converted to B&W using Photoshop. Photographer's Comments: Taken on a wet and cold day at Milford Sound, New Zealand. My intention was to show the grandeur of the Sound and how insignificant we are in the setting. |
Image doctor's advice
Hi Christopher,
Milford Sound is one of the most beautiful places in New Zealand (if not the world) and, were it not for all the rain and the sand flies it would be a great place to live too. Thirty years ago I visited Milford Sound with a couple of mates, and we got there riding push bikes. The ride in was fantastic but getting back out up that hill was a killer!
Two photographers who do live in this corner of the world (Queenstown to be precise) are Mike Langford and Jackie Ranken. One of Jackie's award-winning photographs was made in this same location, probably under this same tree, and it was of Mike holding an umbrella. The difference between your photograph and their photograph was that they chose to make the image from further back and lower down so that you could not see that distracting foreground.
Now, there is a good chance that you have never seen Jackie’s image before – if not, have a look for it on the web.
Perhaps the one thing I am not convinced about in this photograph is the umbrella. For one thing, it is situated directly on the horizon line so it does tend to destroy an otherwise elegant line. One other problem I have with umbrella though is that it does not seem to be raining.
if you want to improve this photograph I would start by the darkening the sky and getting some contrast into those clouds. The next thing I would do is remove the distracting elements from the foreground. Then I would clone the umbrella.
By the time you do this the photograph will look more interesting… like you are really pondering the beauty of Milford Sound.
Cheers, Anthony
Image Doctor's edited version

Recent image doctor critiques
-
Not Talking
by Greg HarrisThis is a nice landscape, though it could be even better if you could pull a bit more life out of those lacklustre clouds. You could try adding a graduated more
-
Let Me Run
by Kip HobsonI don't doubt that the dog is itching to get going, but as for feeling cold, that sounds more like you - quite understandable judging by this shot. This captures more
-
Rachel
by Louise BishopYou have done fine to get those skin tones looking good, and the shot itself is nice and sharp. Where I have a problem is the use of flash which more
-
Sorry Anthony, but you ruined what was an otherwise great shot. With the exception of cleaning up the blob in the foreground, everything else that's been done has really taken away what was good about the photo. In darkening it and attempting to pop the contrast, you've lost detail in the mountains, you've over-sharpened the image so there's some really awful haloing on every hard edge in the image... and we now have a one-armed man standing in the frame (not that I've got anything against handicapped people)... The original shot had a nice misty look about it that still showed detail.
Ren on 06-Sep-12 02:30 PM
The "halo" at the edges of the mountain in the adjusted image worries me a bit, also the total lack of detail in the leaves /branches of the tree and halo's around the branches are a bit distracting. I think also the reeds in the left corner could have been removed. Kind regards
Sonja de Sterke on 06-Sep-12 11:41 AM
Hi, we welcome your comments.
You may comment as many times as you like. We approve and edit comments at our discretion. Do not send us comments that are:
By commenting you agree to our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy . If you wish to alert us about a comment, contact us
Thank you and happy commenting!