AustralianPhotography

image doctor

Luci_anna

Image Doctor: Luci-Anna

Photographer: Ali Lamond

Added: 22-Jun-12

Camera Type: Canon 1D Mk IV

Lens: 50mm

Shutter Speed: 1/250

Aperture: 3.5

Adjustments: Convert to black and white. Spot removal

Photographer's Comments: This picture is of my younger sister who has been helping me with my photography. I was trying to move forward from still, cliche poses and capture some movement (she whipped her hair back and forth).. I quite like it, its not a typical 'portrait' and my sister loves it which is important.

Image doctor's advice

Hi Ali,           

As I opened this image to look at it, a colleague of mine (another pro photographer and occasional judge at the APPAs) looked over my shoulder and gave the picture a thumbs up. That’s good coming from my friend.

I like the image too – the tonal range is good and the angle and lighting are working for you.

There are two things that I would prefer to have seen in this picture though. The first is the hairline… I would have preferred to have seen the framing composed upwards some more so that we can see more of Luci-Anna’s hair. Had you had just a couple of centrimetres of hairline in there it would have added to the framing of her face. Instead, the forehead touching the edge of the composition is providing an exit for our eyes.

My second concern is that hair over Luci-Anna’s lips. The lips are one of the most expressive parts of the face and yet in this instance we have lost them.

At this point I would suggest going back with you sister to the same spot and having another go at this image… remember to pick a similar time of day and conditions to see if you improve in this image.

Going back to reshoot is never easy. I have done it quiet a few times in my career, including a reshoot with a 747 reflected in a terminal building window. The client did not like the look of the model in the of the original image! Despite my best efforts the following day with a different model we never got the same feel and the client ended up using the original image. Then there have been other times when a reshoot has made the difference between an ordinary photo and an award-winning image.

Go and give it a go and see what happens in this instance!

Cheers,

Anthony

reader comments
  • Hi Anthony - thanks for the critique! Ive only been shooting seriously for a few months and will definetly take your advice on board!
    Ali Lamond on 27-Jul-12 07:37 AM

Commenting

Hi, we welcome your comments.

You may comment as many times as you like. We approve and edit comments at our discretion. Do not send us comments that are:

  • abusive or malicious
  • off-topic or excessively long
  • blatantly spam.

By commenting you agree to our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy . If you wish to alert us about a comment, contact us

Thank you and happy commenting!

add a comment







Leave this field empty

* Required field

Recent image doctor critiques

  • Not Talking

    Not Talking

    by Greg Harris

    This  is  a  nice  landscape,  though  it  could  be  even  better  if  you  could  pull  a  bit  more  life  out  of  those  lacklustre  clouds.  You  could  try  adding  a  graduated  more

  • Let Me Run

    Let Me Run

    by Kip Hobson

    I  don't  doubt  that  the  dog  is  itching  to  get  going,  but  as  for  feeling  cold,  that  sounds  more  like  you  -  quite  understandable  judging  by  this  shot.  This  captures  more

  • Rachel

    Rachel

    by Louise Bishop

    You  have  done  fine  to  get  those  skin  tones  looking  good,  and  the  shot  itself  is  nice  and  sharp.  Where  I  have  a  problem  is  the  use  of  flash  which  more

  • Untitled

    Untitled

    by Bob Shaw

    Yes,  you  can  be  quite  happy  with  your  result,  but  is  that  because  it  was  a  test  of  your  skills  or  because  you  really  liked  the  gimmicky  aspect  of  the  more